- Joined
- Jun 7, 2015
- Messages
- 21,469
- Reaction score
- 10,597
1. "He's Donald Trump" is a poor argument. Please provide a reason to think he is racist.
2. When people act as if they dislike something, it isn't crazy to think they dislike it. Does Ilhan Omar dislike Amercia? Maybe, maybe not. But she's certainly made it easy for other folks to think so, which is why she is disliked to such an extent nationally. A really easy way for her to parry this sort of attacks would be to talk about what she likes about America and its people sometimes.
3. This is not a good counter argument. Of course Trump is allowed to say what ideas he thinks are American or unAmerican. So are you. I think the reason the "RACISM!!" strategy was employed by Congressional Dems here is that they fear they will lose this particular debate.
4. Your view that folks on the right see no problems with the US is a strawman. Of course they do.
1. lol What? Are we seriously going to pretend like Trump has no racial "mishaps"?
I'm not going to say he is a straight up racist, but you really going to look at all the "racially insensitive" shit he's said and tell me you can't possibly understand how anyone could come to the conclusion that he MIGHT be a little racist? Properties that he managed not renting to blacks, "They don't look Indian to me"/Indian casino are full of crimes, Death penalty for the innocent 5 black guys that were falsely accused of rape, a Mexican American judge can't properly judge a case because he's Mexican, Shithole countries, "Go back to your country" to black and brown AMERICAN citizens/governemnt workers....that's just off the top of my head. Come on.
2. What do you mean when people act like they dislike something? How did she do that?
What exactly did she say or do that gives you the impression that she HATES America? Again, that she HATES the country that she voluntarily is working for. You don't think that's an incredibly strong statement/charge to make towards someone? How closely do you follow Omar? You're trying to tell me she never talks about her love for the country? Do you think a Muslim Somalian woman was elected in Minnesota on a campaign of how she hates America? With the way news and media is (especially the news that you probably listen to), you're obviously just going to hear "the bad".
She gets this "she hates America" criticism because she wasn't born here. That's it. There's no rule that a refugee or immigrant can't criticize their new country. She's as American as anyone else, and that's her right. She's made some of the same complaints a lot of other people have made/are making, and they're not being accused of hating America.
3. I didn't say he can't say his ideas. He can. But he doesn't get to tell other people that their views are unAmerican. Well, he can, but it's a stupid thing to say. Republicans and Democrats have different views on a range of things, but either side telling the other "you're not American, go away" is not an argument an adult should ever make, especially one that is in government.
4. The right wing only sees problems that have an effect on them. If you criticize the mistakes and wrongs that America has done, it's the right that are ready to yell "You hate America" at you.