CTE is scary . Could head shots be avoided?

Kaiserjuan

Purple Belt
@purple
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
1,518
Reaction score
1,079
At this moment the head shot is really the best and most entertaining shot you can get in striking based combat sports such as boxing and MMA.
Seeing a knowckout is always spectacular especially if it's against someone whe don't like.
Now this would be all great and funny if there were no consequences to it, but there are and they are quite sad to watch.

As a fan of the sport i partially feel responsible for what might very well happen to these young MMA fighters in 10-15 years time. Imagine all your idols whoever these may be (Shogun, Wanderlei, Rampage, McGregor, Lawler etc) become punch-drunk in 10 years time. Now if I had not interest in the sport I could selfishly say: well they knew what they were doing and they knew the risks, so tough on them. But as a fan i feel I am part of the sport or at least of this "system" which allows these people to get chronic, severe brain damage.

For this reason, especially after watching some footage and reaging scientific articles, I ask my self if it is morally acceptable for us fans to let this go on or if we should think of a solution to drastically lower the risk of these fighters turning their brain in a non completely functional one.

Of course completely avoiding headstrikes would be a great albeit drastic solution and maybe it would ruin the sport and the interest it generates. But what if, for example, fighters wore headhear during fights? It could be a good start and the change wouldn't be so drastic. Of course we would have less knockouts and all but at least your brain does get some sort of protection.

Idk, it just baffles me sometimes how I just sit here as a bystander to what is happening and will continue to happen in the sport, especially considering I am a doctor and should be telling people to prevent damage, in particular brain damage which is irreparable as of today.

Now I'm sure some of you will start saying that I'm a pussy and should go watch some other sport, but my issue is not the violence and the gore but rather the longtime consequences that it generates. I don't mind at all seeing a face getting kneed and elbowed or a jaw breaking, or a bone breaking in half. Of course if it happens I feel sorry for the guy but I know that the problem can be solved and that at worse the fighter might have to stop fighting because of a bad leg or a bad shoulder. But CTE, which completely changes your thinking and speaking abilities together with your personality, is really something different and not to be looked upon.
 
I don't think the head gear they wear helps at all. Is there any evidence that proves otherwise?
 
open hand strikes below the neck are the only strikes that should be allowed in mma
 
In amateur level, there should be every measure taken that would lessen head trauma. Currently, there's barely any difference between pros and amateurs except one is getting paid.

As a Judo and TKD guy, I want to try competing mma, but there's just way too much risk for no reward. I could be an mma gym warrior, but that's literally paying money to get my head rattled in meaningless sparring sessions.


They should really work on amateurs
 
CTE is horrible. But it's part of a contact sport. I'm with Rogan on the issue, we just need better science and medicine to figure out how to heal the brain from cte.

Does that mean we shouldn't MMA until that technology is available? I think that's a moral question where the answer depends on the individual. Logically I want to say no, however I watch as much MMA as I can.
 
kyokushin karate

They can still kick and knee to the head in Kyokushin

eecfe33073428a4be9cc3ed727c7d5a0.gif

giphy.gif

kyokushin-flying-knee-ko-o.gif
 
Back
Top