I think objectively the hottest chicks that didn't get into the house were Bethany Marshall and Colleen Schneider. Colleen Schneider's pics were already posted in this thread and it's clear she is much hotter than most of the other girls being named (Roxie? Peggy? REALLY?). Bethany Marshall was possibly the hottest (rewatch her pre-fight interview or Google her if you don't believe me). Out of those who made it into the house, I'd say it's obviously Jessamyn Duke. I don't believe in 'subjectivity' or 'eye of the beholder' when it comes to physical attraction either. Certain features (high cheeks bones, big eyes, thin jaws, etc) are just unanimously considered attractive among all men as it has been proven in studies and experiments.