- Joined
- Oct 30, 2004
- Messages
- 92,446
- Reaction score
- 28,191
While I agree that Pelosi is a very effective vote counter, she was also in charge at a time when the party got decimated at the national level, losing something like 1,000 seats.
The energy of the party is in the progressive policy end. If Pelosi isn’t ready to push real statement votes on issues like Medicare for all, she needs to get out of the way, imo.
I think the job of a politician is to pass good policy, and losses down ballot when a party has the WH are inevitable. You could argue that healthcare reform hurt the party in 2010-2014, for example, but it appears to have helped in 2018. The political aspect is unsettled, but we know that the reforms did a tremendous amount of good for the nation.
I also disagree about where the energy of the party is. There is excitement all over the ideological spectrum, and the suburbs and thriving cities are geographically where the energy is. A recession could shift that (bringing struggling areas, which overwhelmingly go red, in line with other places). Anyway, I think that Medicare for all (at least the opportunity for anyone to buy into it) is a good idea, and I'd expect her to make it happen if she gets the chance and it's at all possible.