Sweet mother of God, it's a more subjective topic by nature, but the weight of subjective opinion isn't in question. The PS4 exclusive library shits all over the Xbox exclusive library.
PUBG is the first really big win in the XB1 column.
What's so great in the XB1 "Console Exclusive" library?
https://gematsu.com/exclusives/xbox-one
PUBG, Cuphead, Ori & The Blind Forest, and
Path of Exile are the console exclusive of note I see in the Download column. Games like
Roblox don't even require a PC. You can play them on a phone.
If an individual is attracted to any of those, specifically, as the TS was in this thread, then it makes perfect sense for that individual to buy for that reason, but if we're going to paint with a wide brush according to overall libraries, without a specific individual as context, then the PS4 > XB1 right now on pure gaming. The dissolution of the PC exclusive wall (at least as it applies to all Microsoft publisher exclusives) is going to take some time to soak in.