- Joined
- Jul 17, 2011
- Messages
- 4,177
- Reaction score
- 1
If it worked we'd see more of it.
Some elements of trapping work great in boxing and the Thai clinch. Some are just too complicated. Simple use of parries and pins, however, are great assets in the clinch and especially with stripping your opponent's clinch off your own neck. Samir Seif on Youtube has some excellent videos explaining this. He's one of those Erik Paulson, well-traveled, try everything martial artist types. He seems like an excellent trainer, and I really like his videos, so I take his word that it works for him and his students. I think he trains one of the current TBA champs.
the thing with Wing Chun that nobody really has addressed is that Wing Chun in its original lineage was built for the street and self defence and were talking about mma which is competitions where you would be gloved giving the mma fighter and advantage, also one of forms of Wing Chun, Bii Gii, it is called or something like that teaches you how to fight when you are at the final point, where your guard is broken and its clinch distance, including groin shots, throat gouges and darting fingers which would be illegal in mma, making it very hard for a true Wing Chun practitioner with a full teaching of the forms to make it in MMA.
Not even sure I'd call that "sparring"
the thing with Wing Chun that nobody really has addressed is that Wing Chun in its original lineage was built for the street and self defence and were talking about mma which is competitions where you would be gloved giving the mma fighter and advantage,
including groin shots, throat gouges and darting fingers which would be illegal in mma, making it very hard for a true Wing Chun practitioner with a full teaching of the forms to make it in MMA.
A Boxer or MMA fighter punching you in the face and knocking you the fuck out is just as good in the ring/cage as it is on the street, ie. your "self defense". How about after you're KO'ed and unconscious on the ground, the MMA starts stomping your skull in against the cement until you die. Is that real enough?
This "self defense" gimmick is what you try to sell to fat chicks and girlie-men who are scared to get hit in the face for real at 70-100% power during sparring.
Yea, and grabbing some guy's nuts on the streets is so amazing and groundbreaking that no one in MMA could ever hope to master right? Basically, you're paying money to some guy to teach you how to grab another dude's nutsack real hard?
Tell me, why does WC also holds tournaments that disallows nut shots, eye jabs, etc.? And while wearing a shit-ton of safety gear on, including what looks like a motorcycle helmet? MMA = 4oz gloves + mouthguard. Which is more brutal?
And eye poking and scratching people's throats, talk about awesomeness. You know, every time I watch a YouTube video where hookers fight, they always scratch and poke eyes too, maybe they are Wing Chun experts. No one else can figure out how to poke eyes nor target throats right except Chuners and hookers right?
Tell me, is this Wing Chun?
8 Ballbusting - BallBustingTube.com - ballbustingtube.com
A Boxer or MMA fighter punching you in the face and knocking you the fuck out is just as good in the ring/cage as it is on the street, ie. your "self defense". How about after you're KO'ed and unconscious on the ground, the MMA starts stomping your skull in against the cement until you die. Is that real enough?
This "self defense" gimmick is what you try to sell to fat chicks and girlie-men who are scared to get hit in the face for real at 70-100% power during sparring.
Yea, and grabbing some guy's nuts on the streets is so amazing and groundbreaking that no one in MMA could ever hope to master right? Basically, you're paying money to some guy to teach you how to grab another dude's nutsack real hard?
Tell me, why does WC also holds tournaments that disallows nut shots, eye jabs, etc.? And while wearing a shit-ton of safety gear on, including what looks like a motorcycle helmet? MMA = 4oz gloves + mouthguard. Which is more brutal?
And eye poking and scratching people's throats, talk about awesomeness. You know, every time I watch a YouTube video where hookers fight, they always scratch and poke eyes too, maybe they are Wing Chun experts. No one else can figure out how to poke eyes nor target throats right except Chuners and hookers right?
Tell me, is this Wing Chun?
8 Ballbusting - BallBustingTube.com - ballbustingtube.com
A Boxer or MMA fighter punching you in the face and knocking you the fuck out is just as good in the ring/cage as it is on the street, ie. your "self defense". How about after you're KO'ed and unconscious on the ground, the MMA starts stomping your skull in against the cement until you die. Is that real enough?
This "self defense" gimmick is what you try to sell to fat chicks and girlie-men who are scared to get hit in the face for real at 70-100% power during sparring.
Yea, and grabbing somhttp://www.sherdog.net/forums/f11/wing-chun-mma-450132/index13.htmle guy's nuts on the streets is so amazing and groundbreaking that no one in MMA could ever hope to master right? Basically, you're paying money to some guy to teach you how to grab another dude's nutsack real hard?
Tell me, why does WC also holds tournaments that disallows nut shots, eye jabs, etc.? And while wearing a shit-ton of safety gear on, including what looks like a motorcycle helmet? MMA = 4oz gloves + mouthguard. Which is more brutal?
And eye poking and scratching people's throats, talk about awesomeness. You know, every time I watch a YouTube video where hookers fight, they always scratch and poke eyes too, maybe they are Wing Chun experts. No one else can figure out how to poke eyes nor target throats right except Chuners and hookers right?
Tell me, is this Wing Chun?
8 Ballbusting - BallBustingTube.com - ballbustingtube.com
Some elements of trapping work great in boxing and the Thai clinch. Some are just too complicated. Simple use of parries and pins, however, are great assets in the clinch and especially with stripping your opponent's clinch off your own neck. Samir Seif on Youtube has some excellent videos explaining this. He's one of those Erik Paulson, well-traveled, try everything martial artist types. He seems like an excellent trainer, and I really like his videos, so I take his word that it works for him and his students. I think he trains one of the current TBA champs.
I practiced WC for close to 5 years.
Just like anything, there are elements that could be useful, and elements that will get you creamed. Some of the centreline theory is very applicable. Some of the blocks are very useful and I have even used them in Muay Thai sparring with effectiveness. I have also used chain punching to throw guys off believe it or not. It's all about using it at the right time and the right place with the right setup.
But if you walk into the cage with only WC as your standup, you're in trouble. Big trouble.