Reyes - I have 4 pairs of Reyes right now (2 hybrids, 1 lace up, 1 velcro-turned-into-hybrids). "
Hard as a rock" isn't how I'd describe any of them. In fact, I think their padding is softer than some other Mexican brands. I use the lace up pair, which is 12oz, for mitt work. Their "hard as a rock" reputation comes from their horsehair fight gloves. The only gloves I avoid people with in sparring are underweight gloves, cheap Everlasts, and gloves that are rated as "bag only", like one or two of the Fairtex models used to be. If you're hitting bags and pads the density of the bags and pads will make more of a difference, as most actual super bag gloves are harder & more dense. Horsehair gloves tend to break down quick on bags, so if you do go that route only use them on pads and expect them not to last as long.
Gil - one of the few Mexican brands I have and I don't like. The wrists on my hybrid 16oz are just way too big for me. I can slide my fully-wrapped hand in and out all the way with the laces tightened fully.
Juan's Torres Medina (TM) brand is really solid. If you want Mexican gloves, he'd be my first stop. Cheaper than NBNL, same ballpark of quality as their fight gloves.
Sabas -
I do believe the dip in quality was temporary. Their prices on their clearance page are worth going for:
@sabasfightgear on instagram.
Sounds like you're getting overwhelmed by reviews. I think step one would be sussing out objective comments on gloves vs subjective comments.
For example, people talk about the uncomfortable thumbs on Reyes as if it's some sort of rule, but fit is very individual. I got my Reyes gloves because I traded for them with a coach who didn't like the fit. Personally, I love how they fit. Mexican gloves have thick leather and take a bit longer to break in a lot of times.
In other cases, it's bias. With Sabas, people have been pushing a claim (with no concrete evidence provided) that they're made in Pakistan as a harsh criticism. In the next post, the same people promote TopBoxer gloves which are definitely made in Pakistan. They're cheap gloves that fit very comfortably for a lot of people (myself included).
If I had it to do over, I would probably recommend to start with the cheapest model(s) you like and gradually buy more expensive ones, only buying the more expensive ones if you find the cheaper ones inadequate. Nothing worse than buying a super expensive glove and realizing you don't like them. Also, make sure you break them in! Some gloves are miserable to use for the first 2 weeks to a month and then they become a part of you. One or two sessions is not going to cut it in a lot of cases. It's more of a matter of whether or not those sessions are too miserable to grind out.