Here's my dream card assuming all guys are at their peaks (or specific period) with heels listed first and US only. I am only limiting it to 9 matches to fit an ideal my ideal 4 hour show. Alternating gimmick matches with traditional matches to keep it from being too gimmicky yet not mundane.
NWO Hogan (1997) vs Austin (1998) for the World Title
Shawn Michaels (1997) vs AJ Styles (2005/2017) in an Iron Man Match
Ray Stevens (1965) vs Ricky Steamboat (1989) for the IC belt
Anti-American Hart (1997) vs Angle (2003) in a Submission Match
British Bulldogs (1986) vs Hardy Boyz (2001) for the World Tag Team Title
Macho Man Randy Savage (1987) vs Undertaker (2005) in a Hell in a Cell match
Flair (1989) vs Brian Danielson (2013)
Piper (1983) vs Rock (2001) in an I Quit Match
Vader (1993) vs Goldberg (1998)