Whose UFC Career Disappointed You the Most?

FreddieRoachsVoice

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
Mar 16, 2018
Messages
3,412
Reaction score
4,046
Whether it was failing to live up to the hype, sticking around too long, or just never reaching their full potential, whose UFC career disappointed you the most?

Here's a few of mine that spring to mind:

- Ben Rothwell: A big name in mma at the time he joined the roster but he only fought 10 TIMES despite being on the roster for 9 years! Every big win he had went nowhere and a lot of interesting matchups (vs Cro Cop, vs Werdum, vs Stipe) fell through because of injuries or suspensions. He could have been a reliable gatekeeper or unlikely contender for years but instead, he has faded into obscurity.

- Little Nog: Similar to Ben, Little Nog came in with a big name and was just never able make it to the cage consistently. Probably the most injury prone fighter in history, it was nearly impossible to get excited for one of his fights because he was likely to pull out 90% of the time. Many Pride dream matches were ruined because of this and the barren wasteland that is the 205 division could still have a name floating around if Diet Nog's career panned out.

- Big Nog: A top 3 HW and one of the most beloved fighters in mma history prior to joining the UFC, Nog was a bit too battle torn to fight at the same level as he did in Pride. Once known for being classy and durable, Nog got finished... a lot once joining the UFC roster and became infamous for making Tito Ortiz level excuses about the losses which really tainted his legacy to some.

- Shogun: Ranked #1 in the world when he arrived, Shogun could have been champ for years to come but despite being young, his knees had too many miles on them for him to regain his old form. His win over Machida was one of the most epic in history, but it's still disappointing to have never seen him string together a real streak of great performances.

There are plenty more examples to think of (Jones, Cro Cop, Anderson, Machida, etc). Whose UFC career do you associate the most with feelings of disappointment?
 
Erick silva, but hes only 19 he has lots of time to improve and go on a title run!
 
Perhaps not a classic answer, but I just have to go with KJ Noons.
 
Definitely Cro Cop for me. All time favorite fighter, he was in great form in 2006 and had won the OWGP. The Gonzaga loss was devastating and he never got it all the way together in the UFC.
 
Definitely Cro Cop for me. All time favorite fighter, he was in great form in 2006 and had won the OWGP. The Gonzaga loss was devastating and he never got it all the way together in the UFC.
Has to be Cro Cop. I still refuse to watch his UFC run beside the Gonzaga rematch.
 
Conor. So much potential but cherry picks fights and refuses to defend.
 
Wasnt a let down but always felt bad for Hendo not getting that gold strap after being 2-division Pride champ.

He had 3 chances against prime Rampage, prime Silva, then a robbery vs Bisping
 
Nick Diaz.

When he came back to the UFC and beat BJ the way he did I was so fucking pumped.
 
Dennis Lang. If you’re an oldschool fan you remember how promising he was
 
Definitely Cro Cop for me. All time favorite fighter, he was in great form in 2006 and had won the OWGP. The Gonzaga loss was devastating and he never got it all the way together in the UFC.
The Schaub loss was hard to watch.
 
Nick Diaz -Love his fights, but he's a drama queen, and stopped caring enough to fight.
BJ Penn - Didn't know when to exit... didn't know how to fight at his proper class.
Cain - We will never know how great he could've been.
CroCop - no explanation needed.
Rory - UFC just let him go.... this is more disappointment in the company than him as a fighter.
Hunt - Should've stayed in kickboxing if he was going to never learn to grapple.
Carwin - back issues derailed such a great power puncher. Not really his fault.

edit -

taknori gomi

This one reminds me of Penn.... just stop dude.... please stop.
 
Last edited:
Shogun and Big Nog were champions, at least, after so many wars at PRIDE i think it's understandable that once champs they weren't dominant. (and Big Nog would've beat the shit of Lesnar and then submitted him, Mir was a terrible match up)

Melvin Guillard was always the monster no one wanted to strike with, but never improved his grappling game, i wonder how far he could have gone with Lawler/Aldo TDD level.

Tim Kennedy and Uriah Hall also comes to mind, 2 guys that looked promising while fighting outside, Tim obviously being a former contender at SF having a good fight with Rockhold, and ends with a 3-2 record at UFC losing to a welterweight-sized chicano. Hall and his .500 record was also unexpected.
 
Back
Top