- Joined
- May 25, 2018
- Messages
- 2,602
- Reaction score
- 197
I agree about the debates being more of a spectacle, but the modern presidency requires a significant degree of charisma and showmanship. You shouldn’t decide who is best fit to run the country exclusively based on debate performances, but in yangs case he seemed so nervous and unprepared it hurts his credibility as a candidate.
I'm not so sure about that charisma bit. Yes it's an asset but... I'm Canadian. If you're not you probably don't remember this guy:
That's Stephen Harper and he was our last prime minister who had 9 years in office, I think. He had to deal with the great recession and under his leadership we saw Canada's economy improve well beyond the global average during what was a pretty rough time for everyone. He was a Conservative and I wasn't a huge fan of some of his social policies but, all in, he was a very solid leader.
The thing is that he was the opposite of Trudeau insofar as he was unobtrusive. He wasn't charismatic, he wasn't great to listen to and didn't stick out in your mind... He was a forgettable guy who came in, did his job quietly, and got things done. He was ultimately a very solid PM in hindsight. Will he go down in history books as one of the greats? Nope - but he ran the country well in his quiet, unobtrusive, uncharismatic way.
Harper was a different beast than Yang, no doubt, but we do not need these strong personalities in office to run a country well. In fact, I daresay they may be becoming a liability. Unfortunately it's because of shit like the debates that those personalities are so heavily weighted - because we think we need some kind of a loudmouthed movie star or smooth talking con man type to waltz onto the global stage and approach politics like a slick used car salesperson would. I think we desperately need people to accept leaders who are a lot less about talk and show than the current band of misfits coming down the pipeline. We need a few more Stephen Harpers, people who just show up, do the bloody job, and don't make their personality central to the issue.
Last edited: