Bathtubber here and I FREAKING LOVE THIS THREAD!!!
Charles can have the mightiest resume in the world - heck, he could've been on a thousand-fight win streak before fighting Islam - AND YET ISLAM STILL BEAT THE BRAKES OFF CHARLES, when they fought!!!
Point is, threads like this are equal parts asinine and infantile. You're ultimately shooting yourself in the foot when the other guy you're supposedly denigrating actually dominated your guy when it actually counts.
Win streaks and redume don't mean jack shit when arguing who is better when there is actually actual proof who is better. Reality, i.e. the actual fight, renders everything moot.
Poor souls, you lot. Can't even muster enough computing power to mount a sound argument.
Just enjoy the fights and quit throwing tantrums when reality becomes incongruent to your precious feelings.
Both great fighters, it needs to be said. One is just a tad better than the other.