Damn - I'm going to have to come back to this. My job might have me move to Seattle in the next year.
Bukowski. I need a response here.
In truth, Seattle is a nice enough city, but some of the things on that list are actually pretty true. It's a city which likes to sniff it's own farts for how progressive it thinks it is when, if you've lived in somewhere really world class, it actually seems quite backwater and redneck on all but a few issues.
It also has a pretty bad case of "that other city" syndrome and a chip on its collective shoulder because of it. It's one of the largest, most important American cities which, if you mention its name overseas, people won't know where the hell you're talking about. It's rarely featured in movies, it's not the home of any really big historical sites, and it's often overshadowed in international acclaim by the increasingly popular Vancouver. Many people are like Sam - they are outright hostile if you aren't there with them saying "Oh yeah, Seattle is the best place in the world" and telling them Vancouver is better is like a declaration of war. It does have some things going for it, but nothing to *really* make it stand out.
Then there is the weather. It's mild, so you don't tend to get massive, long lasting snowfalls or cold spells - and that comment about the city being crippled when it gets a half inch of snow is NOT a joke - but the rain! The city spends much of the year grey, dreary, wet, and generally miserable. You might prefer this to getting really cold, you might prefer this to it being really hot. The mild and oftentimes wet and rainy weather suits some people. For a lot, it is the "grey, cold and humorless shithole" described in that one post.
Comments about the fashion sense there are spot on too - it and Vancouver do the same damned thing. If you go there, get used to seeing lots of spandex and yoga pants in places you wouldn't expect to see them, and on people who the Lord almighty did not intend such things for. You'll also learn that when an old man is biking in spandex, many brands stretch enough so that you can see *everything* underneath.
Then there is the bigotry. Just to be clear, if you're in Seattle, you *cannot* use the N word or discriminate against black people or Latinos on pain of death, but hating Asian people is totally cool. Little snide comments, slurs on their ethnicity, talks about them "invading," and all sorts of passive aggressive closet bigotry that seems like it's straight out of the deep south is common there - as long as it's directed towards Asians. It's really quite shocking seeing as how the city residents seem to want to give every black or Latino person they come across a hand job based on ethnicity. These stuck up pricks will act pretty much the way the worst you'll find in Texas do towards Latinos, but towards Asians, in one breath, then have a nice little back patting session about how backwards Texas is compared to them in the other - the denial is shocking at times.
The arts scene is very good though. They get a good number of concerts and some really awesome opera. You get access to some decent cruises, you're a relatively close drive to a lot of very neat west coast things. The area around it does have some beautiful, lush, temperate rainforest/mountain type scenery. I'm not actually sure I would call Seattle overrated mainly because, seriously, out of American cities worthy of note, who the hell really talks about Seattle outside of their football team recently? It's always "the other guy." It's mainly Seattlers high on their own farts - looking at Sam here - who rate it so damned highly. Nobody else really gives a damn about Seattle. It has its ups and its downs and a lot of people find it a wannabe world class city that's high on itself when in reality it's like this fusion of redneck and half-assed progressive with shitty weather and not much to really make it stand out from other big cities out there.
Edit: One last comment... If you're a South Park fan, watch episode 3 of this season. The whole "sodasopa" thing is something you'll see a *lot* of in Seattle. What does the whole foods guy say? "I've never seen a town that tries so hard to exaggerate its level of social awareness" or something like that? Yeah, hello Seattle!