- Joined
- Nov 26, 2003
- Messages
- 10,039
- Reaction score
- 8,363
Says the dumbass that posts miscitations of every damn article that you post.
So clarify your position? Jews have a right to a state in Israel?
Edit: nice 3x ninja edit - clarify your position please so that I don’t need to strawman you. I am trying to steelman you.
Jews that immigrated after being in Europe for over a thousand years do not have a right to displace Palestinians that have been there the entire time. Learn to read. They do not have a right to displace. Because they're the SAME FREAKING PEOPLE except Palestinians stayed the entire time. Pretty simple what I'm saying.
I never stated Jews do not have a right to live in Israel, Israel shouldn't exist or any of the bullshit nonsense you're dishonestly trying to pin on me.
And I'll say it again: What you're doing is a strawman. Arguing against a position I never said and then getting morally indignant about it. "How dare you say Israel doesn't have a right to exist!!" Uhmm that's not what I said.
1. The Jews who returned to the region were expelled mainly by the Romans (and Assyrians and Babylonians to a minor extent). The ones who returned endured centuries of persecution and racism in their respective regions. The Holocaust was a huge wake-up call to those who weren't entirely convinced that a Jewish state was necessary. There are also Jews who have continuously lived in the region for over 3000 years.
Jews enduring persecution and racism in European pogroms is not the fault of the Palestinians. How is that relevant? Jews enduring hardship does not excuse them doing it to other people.
As for the Native Americans, yeah, theoretically they could expel us if they happen to wage war against us and win. Key emphasis on the word "win." Will it ever happen? Highly doubtful.
In the end, it doesn't matter. Israel won the wars fair and square and was successful in its efforts to establish a Jewish state.
Your initial statement was that Jews are indigenous implying they have the moral authority to take the land. My statement is that the Palestinians are the same fucking people except they just ended up staying.
And to your other statement that Israel won "fair and square" - according to that logic, the Palestinians have every right to wage war against Israel.
So it's ok for Palestinian groups to attack Israel? Didn't the Jews get kicked out by the Romans "fair and square"?
Last edited: