TS is asking advices on how to lose weight by running. I don't think he has a NFL full of PEDs athlete body composition to start with.
But the rest is a matter of semantics. Let me explain myself:
Obese means over 25% of bodyfat for men and over 33% for women. That is a medical definition regardless of what people think or use the word for.
You are referring to "morbidly" obese that is another definition and I think it's above 40% bodyfat on men (I can't remember). I never said TS is morbidly obese... he could be but I don't know.
And yes.. BMI calculators are bullshit since they only take into consideration the height and weight. LOL.
I'm 5'8 and 135lbs at around 10/12% BF (I'm really lean right now, have a small frame and just a little bit of muscle).
If I only add fat I would be technically obese at 155lbs (and the worst looking skinny fat in the world).
Yeah well obviously I agree about TS considering the guy made the topic and says he's in between fat and obese. I'm just saying he's probably not actually obese.
I've never heard of it being defined by BF%, but I've always seen it defined by BMI. I could be wrong there but that's what I was going off of and what wikipedia says.
Even going by a BMI calculator, 5'7 200lbs is "31.3" and barely qualifies as obese. That's based on BMI which we agree on is trash.
Idk it really depends man, it sounds to me like you're just someone who's very lean and likes being lean and smaller. Trust me, from personal experience of pretty much walking around very lean for years at ~135-155lbs myself when I was like 16-20 years old. I know, I used to care a lot about having a "6-pack" and being "ripped" in my own mind, psychologically I really didn't want to gain any fat.
So I think I understand where you're coming from, but I really just can't call someone like Frank Mir for example, obese. He's not. Even if the BMI says he's actually super obese, or his BF% might be 20-27% too. He's just not.
Now maybe TS is obese, because we don't actually even have a clue. There's no pictures, there's no BF% estimate given or lean mass. But I'm just saying someone could be this height/weight, and not just pro athletes or BBs, and not be freaking obese lol. Even at 25% BF someone would probably just look like a tank, like Matt Serra. Not like the typical walmart scooter shopper. So I guess it's based on your interpretation of the word obese here, because BMI and medical definitions aren't always "good". The FDA doesn't always have good recommendations for example, in fact a lot of them are fucking terrible.