Tom Cruise or Edward Norton - Who deserves an Oscar more? (First Semi-Finals)

[I Am Legion]

I think both could be deserving. But as a fan of cinema, Cruise commits and gives us the experience movies were intended for. He could certainly win a Lifetime Achievement like Jackie Chan did. No actor alive has a resume like him, hits galore, great performances galore.

But, he is also the type of guy involved in an absolutely ridiculous cult which he chose over his daughter with Katie Holmes. I have major respect issues with people that can believe such drivel.

 

[HARRISON_3]

Primal Fear
American History X
25th Hour

That’s a respectable list.

 

[Randlewand]

Edward Norton, American History X and it's not even close.

But sherdoggers have a hardon for Cruise and top gun

 

[BluntForceTrama]

this isnt a fair comparison imo
and Im not a huge tom cruise fan per se

But Ill pretty much see every movie if Cruise is in it

The only other actors who make a good flick just about everytime is Daniel Day Lewis and Clint Eastwood

 

[BluntForceTrama]

Norton is a much better actor. Tom is a star with loads of charisma but just a decent actor.

is he though? hes pretty much the same guy in every movie....like marky mark

 

[dc007]

is he though? hes pretty much the same guy in every movie....like marky mark

Tom, yes. Ed, no.