Just going off of what I enjoyed the most this year, not necessarily what was the best. I haven't spent a ton of time on BG3 so I can't really give it my vote. Blasphemous II was up there for me as well.
I would probably go (based off of what I played):
1.) CP2077 PL - This entire package is fantastic. Is this game, in it's current state even without the expansion, was released at launch, it would be considered an all time title. I urge people to give this game a shot and take it in, delving into the world CDPR has created. I've gone back to it just like I did Witcher 3. It deserves your time.
2.) RE4 Remake
3.) Dead Space Remake
Hey, I'm sucker for nostalgia, survival horror and pantheon level titles getting best in class remakes. These are both exceptional games. I loved them when I was younger. I love them now.
4.) Blasphemous II: I love a challenge. I love a side scroller. Metroidvania titles are my thing. The soundtrack is great. It's creative. I had a ton of fun with it.
5.) Diablo IV.
I'm sure when I'm more than ten hours into BG3, it'll knock Diablo off the list and I'll get to AWII when one got time next year and it's on sale, but I just don't have a ton of time to game nowadays.