After the heel hook controversy with Pena, people were asking why his own coach was yelling at him after. Then some stuff came out about him having a rep for hurting teammates in the gym, getting kicked out of Alliance for it, etc.
It seems in that situation people were able to take information in the overall context and color a perception from it just fine. I don't recall anyone saying that we needed to wait until Alliance gym guys filed assault charges that resulted in convictions. Nobody was saying that Alliance violated due process by kicking him out without a verdict of guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. We didn't get a bunch of helpful reminders that his former training partners may have just been crazy and made up stories about him for attention because they were jealous that he was finally getting good.
Strangely none of that stuff happened at all. People just looked at the overall pattern and updated their perceptions accordingly.