- Joined
- Dec 31, 2009
- Messages
- 4,558
- Reaction score
- 3,529
It was a cool movie but it was a damn shame All Quiet On The Western Front didnt wint best movie. It deserved the win but won 4 other Oscars
saw it when it came out around a year ago or whatever. i'm a hipster A24 simp, so take it with a grain of salt i guess, but i loved it and it was my favorite movie of 2022.I see imdb reviewers are writting movie is overrated.
What are your thoughts ?
It’s slow at times but very entertaining in others. Need a good attention span imo. Has some really excellent peak moments tooStarted watching it and then turned it off in the first quarter but might give it another shot
It was enjoyable, but it's one of those "Well, that was kind of fun and unique, but I'm never going to watch it again" type movies. If people say it's some kind of GOAT film or something - which I know some are - I'd say it's overrated. If people are saying it's a good flick that's worth a watch, I'd say they're spot on.
I will also say, we're hearing more about it than we should because it fits in with some narratives of social empowerment.
Honestly, give it a watch. On its own merits, you'll probably like it.
IMDb reviews are right. Overrated film in yet another terrible year for high cinema.I see imdb reviewers are writting movie is overrated.
What are your thoughts ?
IMDb reviews are right. Overrated film in yet another terrible year for high cinema.
What’s women talking aboutI saw the movie and I liked it. I would call it easily a top three movie of the year, maybe the best one.
Is it my favorite Best Picture winner of all time? No... But people who are asking if it's really a "best picture" quality movie and the same for the acting awards and so on...to answer that question knowledgeably you would have to watch the rest of the nominees and if you do then my guess is most people would stop asking whether Top Gun Maverick or Everything Everywhere are actually "Oscar caliber" movies and instead start lamenting that the rest of the movies in general are so poor that Top Gun and Everything Everywhere were easily nomination caliber in a year like this.
If you want an example of a woke movie...forget about Everything Everywhere and instead go and be almost literally preached to for two hours by Women Talking.
Of the last five years at the Oscars, 2019 was maybe the only one where it was even an average year for quality of Best Picture nominees as opposed to well below average or even abysmal. Nomadland in 2020 was maybe the weakest Best Picture winner of all time...but look at the other stuff that made the nominee list like Trial of the Chicago 7 and Mank and so on. 2021...Power of the Dog, Don't Look Up, Licorice Pizza. This year was no better.
I wouldn't hold it against Everything Everywhere for being the tallest movie at a midget convention. There is both a relative dearth of classics being made and also some fart sniffing going on in the nomination / selection process to get the supposed "top ten" of the year. Unlike most of the nominees of the last five years, I think Everything Everywhere actually would deserve a nomination in a pretty strong year for film.
What’s women talking about
It's about a Mennonite colony, a sort of Amish type backwater religious community, where some of the women of the community have been drugged and raped in their sleep by a few of the men at the colony. This sort of thing actually did happen in real life and this was inspired by a specific incident. But this was all before the movie begins.
The movie itself is a fictionalized account of how the women might have gone about deciding what to do in response. They more or less have the choice of whether to stay and forgive the attackers or to pick up and leave collectively.
I think a movie about this real life incident or about the real life legal proceedings that ensued could have been a very good and important film. But as executed instead it was kind of just an essay about gender relations that wasn't terribly nuanced and struck me as somewhat hamfisted.
I thought it would be something kind of like an all-female Twelve Angry Men with all kinds of ebbs and flows in the debate and various viewpoints and so on. It wasn't really like that.