Man, you really do just keep doubling down don't you?
The entire argument was about his defending against his TITLE CONTENDERS. You're the one who moved it to instead say he fought the guys in his division as divisionally ranked, not how they're in contention for title shots.
Which yes is an entirely different thing and moving the goalposts, especially when you're referencing Arman who wasn't even ranked when he fought Arman in Arman's short notice UFC debut 5 years ago.
Islam has never defended against his #1 contender, let alone #2-4 title contenders. Volk wasn't in contention in either fight and Poirier's 5th right now behind Arman, Max, Charles, and Justin.