The fashion industry is run by gay men, so that isn't really a strike against the guy's point. Vanity isn't much of a selling point for most women.
Yeah, good point. Guys fall into the illusion of believing that what they perceive as attractive is in line with women's views. Just the other day i saw a pool with a photo of the same guy, both bald and after micropigmentation, and the men voted the micropigmentation one was the better looking version of the guy and the women voted for the bald version.
Not to say Luke is an ugly guy. But when i look at him i don't think "uhh, i wish i had his face". With young brad pitt i do. With this guy, not really. And i've showed pics of him to quite a few females after seeing shertards drool so much over him and none of them seemed impressed at all.
He does have a very well built body, but that's about it. His skin is way too fucked up for his age and he has a weird, washed out, goofy/smug smile that i really wouldn't wish for myself.
Again, not saying he is an ugly person, but i highly doubt women would drool as much over him as shertards do. I'm willing to bet most would consider him average in terms of face and hot in terms of body. And maybe older women would like a guy like him, but a hot young college girl can easily get a guy considerably prettier than luke at her college campus.
The dude isn't exactly 35 yo brad pitt.