What's your favorite of the most popular flavors of ice cream?

Which of these is your favorite flavor?


  • Total voters
    118
Mint chocolate chip is always a go to. Nothing wrong with cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie dough
 
Cookies and cream
Coffee
Strawberry

Blue Bunny Banana Split is one of my favorites
 
Whatever @revoltub doesn't eat. Cause he's a dork and I don't wanna associate with that kind of thing.
 
So ice cream in general has been on a decline. I can't stand the gums they put into the shit. Even most of the premium makers have been turning their crap into monstrosities like Wal-Mart got caught selling as ice cream sandwiches (remember when it went viral you could leave those out in the hot sun and they wouldn't melt?).

Remember the Breyers commercials?


Breyers today...
pbic04.png


But it's about more than that. I swear, they're just using cheaper ingredients or something. Thin milk, I swear. Ice cream has gone downhill. Only the super premium brands like Ben & Jerry's and Haagen Daaz taste like they always did, but they're like $7 a goddamn pint, now.

One company that was bucking that trend was the company better known for cheese: Tillamook. Just seemed to be focused on better ingredients. Well, obviously my taste buds weren't the only ones that figured it out. Their prices have soared recently. They attributed that to an increase in cost of their raw ingredients, which I'm sure is true, but I also don't doubt it's due to demand. Because they have comparatively shot past the prices of other brands that used to charge more (ex. Breyers, Dreyer's)-- at least where I live.

Their Mint Chocolate Chip is phenomenal. The quality of the dark chocolate that makes up the chips is astounding. It's better than what Hershey's and Ghiradelli's are selling as straight chocolate bars.

Tillamook_04052020152615.png


Make ice cream great again.

Notice how the Breyer's ingredients list starts with "Frozen Dairy Desert"?

They actually can't legally call anything Ice Cream unless it meets a certain threshold of milk fat, I believe. Don't buy anything that isn't actual ice cream because it will never taste as good.
 
Ones that I like from the list, in order of prefference:
Chocolate
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Mint Chocolate Chip
Vanilla & Chocolate
Chocolate Chip
Coffee
Vanilla

Not on the list that would slot in right below the cookie dough:
Fudge Swirl
Caramel Swirl
 
Peanut butter and chocolate. On the list probably salted caramel.
 
Moose tracks and anyone who says otherwise is a psychopath.
 
I voted Butter Pecan(I love it, and it's also my dad's favorite), but Cookies and Cream is my 2nd favorite, and the real GOAT.(Strawberry with fruit chunks is 3rd) Vanilla can fuck off, it's a cheat code because of toppings...try being forced to eat that shit plain/without cake or on pie...it sucks.
 
Last edited:
Apparently good ole Chocolate Chip is disappearing. It's down to #14-- out of the Top 10 completely. Which of the Top 15 is your favorite?

1. Cookies ’n Cream
2. Vanilla
3. Chocolate
4. Mint Chocolate Chip
5. Strawberry
6. Butter Pecan
7. Coffee
8. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
9. Caramel/Salted Caramel
10. Cookie Dough
11. Birthday Cake/Cake Batter
12. Moose Tracks
13. Vanilla & Chocolate
14. Chocolate Chip
15. Rocky Road

I go to a place that makes homemade ice cream, and the Ginger, grape nut, and Lemon ice cream are fuckin outstanding.

So is the pumpkin pie, and blueberry.
 
Back
Top