It's based on the only thing i can count on experience also on research article i found on the subject. Whenever i compare comparing synthetic poly foams or syntetic laytex foams/rubber that are made to substitute natural latex, latex is always better. or perform better especially in the application as a sparring glove.
here are 2 references from a article i read that sums it up nicely
- Physical testing results indicate that quality latex foam rubber is capable of exceeding the physical performance of flexible polyurethane foam, however the density and cost of latex foam rubber is also much higher.
- The use of filler materials in latex foam rubber does not improve most physical performance attributes.
the more filler a latex foam has the more synthetic and cheaper it becomes.
Well, with respect this
http://www.pfa.org/intouch/new_pdf/lr_IntouchV.8.pdf is not much a research article. Just a 12 years old short article from Polyreuthan Foam Association. Do you think it is a valid argument to claim ALL synthetic foams are worse than latex? Would not say so.
Btw do you really believe in what you are saying?
i would assume winning mostly uses synthetic foams cause they are easily available in japan, while trying to get the same quality in latex might be harder/more expensive to source but i could be wrong
Winning are so greed so they save (as you claim) on materials the amount equal to 5-10 minutes salary of the JPN emloyee? Really?
In the ms-600 winning glove they use 3 layers of foam i would argue the fact that it's the combination of the 3 layers that gives winning it's durability especially on the bag. i'll have to test it myself to confirm.
I do not claim the particular number of layers is what makes it durable. The only thing I claim (though it is maybe not enough "proved by science" unlike Hayabusa Tokushu
). The only thing I do claim is the durability itself. Based on the use of gloves. Not on mattresses, pillows, condoms or sexy clothes, but on Winning gloves used daily by myself and most importantly by many pro. This is the only real proof of durability of the padding in case of boxing gloves imo.
as for water damage to laytex this is the first i've heard of it. i know you can use water to clean latex foam mattresses, if water would damage latex im sure they would not suggest this.
Sorry, admit my mistake. Water does not cause much damage, but some oils do. However if latex absorbs water it never fully dries then.
That would be personal preference on the style and cut of the glove i would argue that the cleto reyes padding itself is more comfortable then the padding in the winning gloves. As for the glove design and cut i perfer the winning gloves over the cleto reyes gloves for my long hands but that is only my personal preference and really shouldn't mean much to others, unless they had the same preference for a glove as i do. As for my respond being pointless and general maybe it is but without giving out specific details on how the gloves are constructed that is all i can do, plus i seem to have gotten off track into quality and sourcing sorry about that.
Yes and no. Winning padding is way softer than Reyes, for this reason Winning fit better. Though many people prefer Reyes... why not in the end.
padding in top ten gloves = laytex rubber foam mold
Ringside IMF tech gloves = laytex rubber foam mold
Cleto Reys = laytex foam sheets
Rival = in their sparring gloves i've seen laytex foam sheet
Dude, bayfill is polyreuthane, it's a shame you do not know this. Even I have mentioned it here several times, but nobody reads my posts lol
http://www.bayermaterialsciencenaft...m=EB7C4AFE-91DF-50A0-4BF8AEF5B03A8835&o_num=5
Do not know anything about Ringsde foam material, however would hardly call them top gloves
They are good though.
Reyes I've already mentioned, the same in case of Grant.
Do not know anything about Rival sparring gloves foam beside I do not like them.
I don't know i never used their 2" extra padded gloves if they are off by so much i'm sure it was human error or they should look into better quality control.
They are the same as the standard Reyes, just claim to have more padding over knuckles (one of the gloves did not) and are quite disproportioned. But many Reyes gloves are disproportioned. Very often the right glove is different from the left one. They simply cut, fill somehow them and than sew the gloves in Reyes. Nothing like putting all the materials before it on the accurate scale like they do in Winning. This is not a lack of quality control, but the lack of professionalism in the manufacturing process.
i know is that i know what winning uses in there gloves and headgear that i've opened up and i will use what i like and discard the rest in my own gear. I think our first batch of kong gloves had pretty crazy padding but i'm just going to build on that.
I did not dissect my Winning gear. I just use it. This is what I know.
Anyway, good luck in trying! Many people claimed this, nobody have succeded yet. Honestly I would be very glad if you succeed, you are a nice guy.
reasons i back latex over synthetic foams is that it's a natural product made from the sap from the rubber tree, it's hypoallergenic and is resistant to bacteria. which is good.
A good joke, mate.
"Latex is hypoallergenic" :icon_lol:
Btw latex itself is not resistant to bacteria, the treament done to it helps latex to be quite resistant.
Beside this all you still haven't explained what valuable addition will latex bring if added to the Winning foam.
Basicallly you say latex is better than any synthetic. Why do you bother copying Winning synthetic foam then?
Ask Manny or Floyd why do they buy Winning gear. Performance is the reason. Neither Reyes, nor Grant (most probably 2 the very best latex brands) perform as well as "the cheaper Winning synthetic".