What is your plan to get rid of the joint discomfort in your knees? I've been battling with some pain above the knee caps for months now, and I wouldn't be able to do any heavy squatting movements without my knee sleeves. I also feel it's related to quad tightness, but foam rolling and stretching only seem to temporarily alleviate the pain.
Hey Spacebar, I'd say if you're having only limited success you might want to graduate your efforts and see if they give more results. If I were you I'd definitely schedule a few massages, say at least once a week for 3-4 weeks, that focus on getting the knots out of your quads and realigning the fibers, as well as separating the muscles from one another. The vastus group and the lateral hamstrings tend to get really adhered, as do the vastus group and the adductors. As well, the v. intermedius can get super stuck to the femur, and since it's so deep foam rolling rarely gets to it. If you get to a good LMT and tell them what you want (is the above paragraph) you should do just fine.
As far as foam rolling and stretching go, I'm not sure what you're currently using to SMR, but often times people stick to "foam rollers" when they'd be better served by using medicine balls or even PVC rollers; essentially, you need to get in there and really try to separate the muscles and get rid of the deep adhesions, the ones that are causing the joint space to become restricted and sending pain signals.
Great work on the random POS leg press!
Thanks man lol
Damn - that is a lot of weight on the leg press!
I have a question, though. Every time I've used the leg press it's really bothered my patella. I would think that since a the hamstrings and gluts take a lot of the shearing force away from the knee with the squat, a good squat would be better on the knees than a leg press, but I don't really know. Can you explain a bit more about the mechanics? I agree though the nice thing about the leg press is the lack of spinal loading.
Also - are you wrapping your knees on the high sets. Even if leg press is a lot easier on the knees than a back squat, a half of ton has to be pretty damn stressful on the joints.
What is your goal with the deadlift? 700?
Anyway - good lifting.
Thanks Enright! My deadlift goal for 2010 is 700 raw (no suit), so we'll see how that goes.
My thoughts on your question are that you might have had your foot placement a little lower than is ideal for posterior chain recruitment, because the lower the feet are positioned on the sled, the more quad dominant the move is, which causes more knee pain. It's still a center of gravity movement, so the lower your feet, the more it mimics someone "squatting on their toes."
You said the hams/glutes take the shearing force away from the knees in a squat, but that's only true in a low bar squat. And since I do a high bar style, where the knees are forced to travel more, it can be a little rougher on my knees than it would be if I switched form over to a low back back squat. But since my back is tweaky and I'm working to get it back to good, I can't switch to a low bar position right now. In fact, that's exactly why I'm working my leg presses, and using a pretty high foot placement - I get more posterior chain recruitment and less knee pressure. So just like with squats you can mimic a high or low bar position with the leg press, depending where you place your feet.
I did want to reference the point you made about the lack of spinal loading in the LP. A few years ago I was doing some research into it and came across a bunch of information and compiled statistics that indicated that the LP was one of if not the most dangerous machine in the gym, for lower back injuries. The reason is because you can load the hell out of it, but most people either don't know to or can't keep 1) their abdomen full of air and braced, and 2) keep a neutral or even arched lumbar spine as they descend. It's SO EASY to let the sled push your knees into your torso and bring your lower back off the pad, which is exactly the same as letting your low back round in a deadlift, that many people seriously strain their lower backs on LP. Crazy huh? So if someones going to do it:
1) Know what stance you want to use and why (high vs low bar, quad or PC recruitment)
2) Valsalva and keep a neutral lumbar spine.
Oh and nope, I don't use knee wraps the way I'm doing it now, and I still don't feel any jt discomfort. I do use my belt though, on the top two or three sets, to help with the IAP.