- Joined
- Aug 29, 2018
- Messages
- 2,409
- Reaction score
- 0
Judo:
Turtle position:
Background:
This is completely anti-Jiu-Jitsu and I understand and agree. As you might already know, the turtle position sometimes is not that simple to defeat (in a quick way), in other words, in Judo if the opponent doesn't do anything (in a timely manner) against a turtle defense then the referee will restart the match standing. Judokas that are very good standing usually don't like to spend to much energy on the ground so they just turtle until the referee do something about it.
Solution:
Penalty whenever the opponent turtles and/or give more newaza (ground grappling) time, if the Judoka that turtles doesnt want newaza then he should restart the match standing via escaping and get back to his feet.
Jiu-Jitsu
Background:
While I understand that the true spirit of BJJ is the ground grappling, the fact of the matter is that in order to go to the ground you need to have a very good standing grappling as well. Of course if you are competing against opponents without grappling/wrestling experience (e.g. gracies) then you don't need an exceptional at standing grappling but nowadays it's pretty obvious how elite BJJ guys are having a very hard time to get a fight to the ground when they are fighting other good wrestlers/grapplers that decide to not go to the ground with them.
Solution:
Some people think they should penalize pulling guard, which it's pretty stupid to be honest. Pulling guard is still a technique that might or not might work. What needs to change is very clear and I know this will never happen since it's against the "spirit" of BJJ but come on think about it, if the opponent doesn't want to go to the ground why you would force him to do so? That's unnatural just like Judo restarting to standing is unnatural as well. What would be the benefit here? well, the guys that are exceptional on the ground will find out that they are having a very hard time and will need to improve their standing game, and the guys who prefer the standing game will find out that sooner or later they will end up on the ground and they will need improve their ground game as well. This will only result in much better well-rounded grapplers.
I would think you could give them a limited amount of time to attack from guard. They can't use it as a defensive. I don't think laying on your back with your legs wrapped around a guy is very pleasing from a spectator standpoint, nor does it promote a good strategy for self defense.
However, the same issue I have with the gripping rules in that you have to attack in a certain period of time (Judo) may transfer over. I don't know how to implement a rule without making it overly prone to penalties. Perhaps remove the clock from both sports? That way stalling isn't a thing.
Point accumulation, submission or pin only?