- Joined
- Jan 23, 2017
- Messages
- 15,538
- Reaction score
- 30,664
They're all interesting fights on their own, I just don't like what they do to the divisions. I'd rather see Islam vs. Gaethje, arman, rematch charles, then fight whoever is next like Benoit or whoever. I miss long title runs and giving whoever is next the opportunity, regardless of whether we think he has much chance to win.
As for Edwarda vs Islam, I find it very interesting as well simply because Edwards has a lot of qualities that I think would give islam fits. I've been saying this for a while, but islam sucks at checking leg kicks and gets away with it because he mostly faces orthodox fighters that don't want to go shin to shin. He also relies on the step back counter left hand, which again is perfect in that open stance. A southpaw will have a much easier time leg kicking islam, and won't be there as easily for the counter left of islams. The southpaw stance also makes the single leg less easily available. It's partially why I'm interested in Benoit's development as well.
That said, I have concerns about Edward's chin and his cardio when people push a pace on him. It's an interesting fight, and I'd enjoy it, but I'd prefer islam stack up some defences at LW since he has 0 against lightweights.
I don't think Islam vs Charles 2 is necessary and Arman needs another win before a title shot. I think having them face each other makes decent sense, otherwise who will Arman face? Gaethje? Chandler? Poirier? Who else besides those is there even? If it's Islam vs Gaethje next, have Arman fight Charles, if it's Islam vs Charles II next have Arman face either Gaethje or Poirier, but neither would want to take it.
Benoit needs good matchmaking now, I'd like him vs Jalin/Hooker which will cement him a top 10 ranking, then you can either try to line him up with Gamrot vs RDA winner or some big name coming off a loss at that time (Poirier, Chandler, Gaethje, Charles) thats how I'd play it anyways. The division isn't that deep, there's very few rising contenders and promising prospects, no reason for Islam to stick around a long time, HE DOES NOT plan to fight past his prime, he won't be in the game at 35-36 like westerners are. Islam has a 13 fight win streak at 155lbs, which is tied for the longest in LW history alongside Khabib, if he reaches 4 title defenses he breaks the LW defense record too. I don't see him sticking around much past 15 fight win streak and 4 title defenses at LW, might as well fight for 170lb title then. Max is 5 defenses as I see it, the challengers and marquee rivals just don't exist at LW.